UK MOD Defends Satcom Resilience Amid SpaceX Starshield Concerns

The UK Ministry of Defence has defended its use of SpaceX’s Starshield service, stressing that it is only one part of its satellite communications infrastructure.
Credit: SAC Britney Leather / UK MOD / Crown Copyright

The UK government has defended the resilience of its satellite-based military communications, saying that while it uses SpaceX’s Starshield service, it does not depend on any single commercial provider for critical communications. The assurance comes amid concerns about reliance on SpaceX after it emerged that restrictions had been placed on Ukraine’s access to the company’s satellite communications services.

The assurance came in response to a parliamentary question from Liberal Democrat MP Helen Maguire, who asked what assessment the Ministry of Defence (MOD) had made of the consequences of losing access to Starlink and Starshield, and how it was ensuring the UK’s strategic autonomy.

Responding on 10 November, defence minister Luke Pollard distinguished between the two services, stating that “Starlink is not used for UK military operations.” He added that the MOD uses Starshield but employs a combination of military and commercial satellite communications capabilities to reduce dependence on any one provider.

In its 2024 report, Ukraine: A Wake-Up Call, the House of Lords International Relations and Defence Committee highlighted the speed and flexibility commercial providers had brought to Ukraine’s war effort. However, it also raised questions about whether companies could be relied upon to maintain continuous service and how they could be held accountable during conflict.

The report cited evidence from RAND space policy analyst Theodora Ogden concerning reported restrictions on Ukraine’s use of Starlink, particularly for controlling unmanned systems in the Black Sea.

The issue returned to parliamentary discussions in October during a hearing of the Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy. MP Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi drew attention to the impact of Starlink restrictions on Ukraine during a discussion about threats to space infrastructure.

“We have seen the devastating impact that Starlink being slowed down and restricted for Ukraine has had,” said Dhesi.

In answers published on 16 November in response to a set of three questions tabled by Liberal Democrat MP James MacCleary, Pollard said the MOD had access to a substantial number of Starshield terminals, although he did not disclose the specific figure on national security grounds.

He explained that decisions to use Starshield were made based on individual military requirements, with the service operating alongside other capabilities. Pollard declined to list specific applications or provide details of the military’s dependence on the service, citing the sensitivity of operational information. He instead described Starshield as an additional communications capability within a broader strategy, providing “operational resilience through diversity”.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here